Async Rust never left the MVP state

Async Rust's compiler implementation generates excessive binary bloat even for simple async functions, with the article demonstrating that a trivial async function produces 360 lines of intermediate code compared to 23 lines for synchronous equivalents—a critical issue for embedded systems and resource-constrained environments. The author proposes compiler-level optimizations, including eliminating unnecessary panic states in released binaries and reducing state machine complexity, which could yield 2-5% binary size reductions for async firmware. For IT organizations, this signals that Rust's embedded and edge computing adoption may be constrained by current async implementation inefficiencies, impacting performance-critical applications and requiring awareness of these technical limitations when evaluating Rust for resource-constrained deployments.

Hacker News3 min read
Read full article
Async Rust never left the MVP state
Async Rust's compiler implementation generates excessive binary bloat even for simple async functions, with the article demonstrating that a trivial async function produces 360 lines of intermediate code compared to 23 lines for synchronous equivalents—a critical issue for embedded systems and resource-constrained environments. The author proposes compiler-level optimizations, including eliminating unnecessary panic states in released binaries and reducing state machine complexity, which could yield 2-5% binary size reductions for async firmware. For IT organizations, this signals that Rust's embedded and edge computing adoption may be constrained by current async implementation inefficiencies, impacting performance-critical applications and requiring awareness of these technical limitations when evaluating Rust for resource-constrained deployments.